Request allocation Contact 简体中文

ScienceTechnical reports

JM-TR-2023-006 Technical report Library v2.8

Library v2.8: explicit modelling of diagenetic modification in phylogenetic placement scoring, and deprecation of manual override flags older than 24 months

Dr. Hao Lin 1,* Dr. Elena Popescu 1 Dr. Anders Kjeldsen 1

1 Jurassic Meat Shenzhen Research Center, Shenzhen, China
* Corresponding author: Dr. Hao Lin · regulatory@jurassicmeat.com

Contents
  1. Abstract
  2. 1. Summary
  3. 2. Introduction
  4. 3. Materials and Methods
  5. 4. Results
  6. 5. Discussion
  7. 6. Limitations and known issues
  8. 7. Changes in Library v2.8
  9. 8. Data availability
  10. 9. Acknowledgements
  11. 10. References

Abstract

Until this release, the Peptide Library scored diagenetically modified residues as if they were sequence. A deamidated asparagine observed as aspartate was treated as an aspartate in the extinct protein. Library v2.8 introduces a diagenesis-aware observation model in which each observed residue is generated from a latent true residue through specimen-specific rates of deamidation (N, Q), oxidation (M, W, H) and in-situ backbone cleavage, with specimen-level diagenetic state informed by Asx racemization where chiral data are available. Applied to the v2.8 library (2,236 theropod-assigned fragments, 12,780 unique residues, 57 extant reference taxa), the model raises median placement posterior from 0.68 to 0.71 and removes the dependence of placement confidence on deamidation load. It reclassifies 1,104 residue calls previously scored as substitutions, including nine of the 31 theropod-diagnostic alignment columns defined in v2.0. The release also inventories manual override records, converted at the v2.0 migration from the v1.x override flags and unflagged manual edits. At the v2.7 freeze there were 4,118 active overrides, 3,342 of them older than 24 months and 1,906 without a recorded rationale. Overrides older than 24 months are deprecated: they emit a build warning and continue to apply pending review. With overrides disabled, median placement posterior is 0.67.

Keywordspalaeoproteomicsdiagenesisdeamidationoxidationracemizationbackbone cleavagephylogenetic placementcuration overridesdata governance

JM-TR-2023-006 · Library v2.8 · 12 September 2023 Dr. Hao Lin*, Dr. Elena Popescu, Dr. Anders Kjeldsen Shenzhen Research Center, Jurassic Meat, Nanshan District, Shenzhen *Corresponding author

Public summary of internal report (full internal version: 46 pages).

1. Summary

  • Library v2.8 contains 2,236 theropod-assigned fragments from 21 specimens, covering 12,780 unique residues, against 57 extant reference taxa. Median placement posterior is 0.71.
  • Placement scoring now models deamidation, oxidation, backbone cleavage and racemization explicitly. Placement confidence no longer declines with a fragment's deamidation load.
  • 1,104 residue calls previously scored as substitutions are now classified as probable diagenetic products, including 9 of 31 theropod-diagnostic alignment columns.
  • An inventory found 4,118 active manual override flags in a library of 2,236 fragments. 3,342 were older than 24 months and 1,906 had no recorded rationale.
  • Overrides older than 24 months are deprecated. They emit a warning at build time and remain in effect until reviewed. At release, 412 had been reviewed.

2. Introduction

Fossil proteins are not pristine copies of the living protein. Over geological time they undergo hydrolysis of the peptide backbone, deamidation of asparagine and glutamine, oxidation of methionine, tryptophan and histidine, and racemization of amino acids from the L to the D form. These modifications matter in two ways. They are evidence: a fragment showing extensive deamidation and in-situ cleavage is more likely to be old than one that does not, and deamidation has been used as an authenticity criterion in the library since the founding work (JM-TR-2013-001) and in the wider field (Cappellini et al. 2019; Welker et al. 2019). Whether any endogenous protein survives in Mesozoic bone at all remains contested (Schweitzer et al. 2009; Asara et al. 2007; Buckley et al. 2008; Saitta et al. 2019), and the persistence of sequence in closed, mineral-bound systems (Demarchi et al. 2016) is the context in which diagenetic signals are interpreted. They are also noise: a deamidated asparagine has the same elemental composition as aspartate, and a fully deamidated N is indistinguishable by mass from a genuine D.

Through v2.3 the library treated these two roles inconsistently. Modification annotations were stored as a separate layer from v2.0 onward (JM-TR-2019-004, Section 3.3), and were used in contamination screening (JM-TR-2021-005, Section 3.3), but placement scoring used the observed residue. Where an observed D or E sat at a position occupied by N or Q in every reference taxon, the placement engine saw a substitution unique to the fossil and, where that substitution was shared across specimens, a potential synapomorphy. JM-TR-2019-004 and JM-TR-2021-005 both listed diagenetic modelling as a limitation scheduled for a future release. This report describes that release.

The second subject of this report is the manual override flag. Override flags have existed since v1.0, when 37 were applied during manual curation, each with a justification and a date, under a shared curation account and without expiry (JM-TR-2014-002); four more followed in v1.2 (JM-TR-2016-003). At the v2.0 migration the 41 flags were converted to structured override records, together with 1,166 unflagged manual edits in the legacy files, so that manual decisions would be visible (JM-TR-2019-004, CA-6). They have been made visible. Section 4.6 reports what is now visible.

3. Materials and Methods

3.1 Library content

Seven specimens (JM-SP-0051 to JM-SP-0057: three teeth, three long-bone fragments and one ungual) were accessioned between April 2021 and March 2023 under the chain-of-custody schema (JM-TR-2021-005). Extraction, LC-MS/MS and identification followed JM-TR-2019-004 and JM-TR-2021-005 without change, with peptide-level FDR of 1% and MaxQuant-type feature processing (Cox & Mann 2008). The extant reference set was expanded from 41 to 57 taxa, principally by the addition of 14 neognath birds, with one further crocodilian and one further turtle.

3.2 Specimen-level diagenetic profiling

For each specimen we estimated six diagenetic quantities from its accepted PSMs (Fig. 1): fractional deamidation of N and of Q, calculated only at sites where N or Q is conserved in all reference taxa, so that an observed D or E at those sites can be attributed to deamidation with high prior confidence; fractional oxidation of M and of W; and the fraction of peptide termini that are non-tryptic, as a measure of in-situ backbone cleavage. For 14 of 21 specimens, chiral amino acid analysis of a separate subsample provided the D/L ratio of Asx (aspartate plus asparagine) in the acid-insoluble fraction, as an independent measure of thermal and diagenetic history.

These quantities were combined into a single specimen-level diagenetic index θ (0–1) by a latent-variable model fitted across specimens. For the seven specimens without chiral data, θ was estimated from the remaining five quantities.

3.3 Diagenesis-aware observation model

The placement likelihood in v2.3 compared the observed residue at each aligned position with the reference profile directly. In v2.8 the observed residue o is modelled as generated from a latent true residue t through a diagenetic transition matrix D(θ), with the substitution model operating on t:

P(o | tree, placement) = Σ_t P(t | tree, placement) · D_θ(o | t)

D(θ) has non-zero off-diagonal terms for N→D, Q→E, and for oxidised forms of M, W and H. Oxidation does not change the residue identity in the alignment but reduces the confidence weight of the call. Rates are specimen-specific through θ and residue-context-specific through a small set of sequence-context multipliers (for example, the elevated deamidation rate of N followed by G). Explicitly annotated deamidation (where the spectrum localises the mass shift) and inferred deamidation (where a D or E is observed at a conserved N or Q site) are treated identically.

3.4 Cleavage and racemization

In-situ backbone cleavage affects scoring in two ways. First, terminal residues created by diagenetic cleavage, rather than by trypsin, have lower identification confidence, and are down-weighted. Second, the length distribution of diagenetically cleaved fragments is shifted toward short fragments, which place poorly (JM-TR-2019-004, Fig. 2); this is reflected in the per-fragment weight. Racemization is not observed directly at the peptide level. It enters the model only through θ, and through a retention-time term that tolerates the chromatographic shifts associated with isoaspartate formation during deamidation.

3.5 Evaluation

We evaluated the model by ablation (Table 3), by the relationship between deamidation load and placement confidence (Fig. 3), and by the change in per-fragment posterior (Fig. 4). Reconstruction targets were re-inferred under v2.8 scoring and compared with v2.3 scoring.

3.6 Override inventory and deprecation

An override is a structured instruction attached to a library entry that takes precedence over automated behaviour. Five types exist: FORCE_INCLUDE, FORCE_EXCLUDE, PIN_PLACEMENT, PIN_RESIDUE and SUPPRESS_CONTAM. Each carries a creator, creation date and an optional rationale. Overrides have no expiry. We inventoried all overrides active at the v2.7 freeze (31 August 2023) and classified them by type, age, attribution and rationale. An override is "older than 24 months" if created before 31 August 2021.

4. Results

4.1 Library content

Library v2.8 contains 2,236 theropod-assigned fragments from 21 specimens (Table 1). The 121 keratin- associated fragments remain flagged (LOWCONF_KAP) and included in default builds at full weight (JM-TR-2021-005).

Table 1. Library statistics, v2.3 and v2.8.
Metric v2.3 (2021-02) v2.8 (2023-09)
Fossil specimens 14 21
Theropod-assigned fragments 1,610 2,236
— collagen type I 1,219 1,677
— enamel proteins 210 303
— other non-collagenous proteins 94 135
— keratin-associated (flagged) 87 121
Unique residues covered 9,410 12,780
Extant reference taxa 41 57
Theropod-diagnostic alignment columns 31 22 (+9 reclassified)
Median placement posterior (theropod) 0.66 0.71
Active override flags 2,690 4,024

4.2 Diagenetic profiles

Diagenetic profiles vary substantially between specimens (Fig. 1). Q deamidation is lower than N deamidation in every specimen, as expected from their relative rates. The founding specimen JM-SP-0001 is among the most extensively modified. Q deamidation correlates with Asx D/L across the 14 specimens with chiral data (Fig. 2; R² = 0.95), supporting the use of both quantities as measures of a shared diagenetic history rather than of contamination, which would be expected to lower both.

Figure 1. Diagenetic profile by specimenFractional N and Q deamidation (at reference-conserved sites), M and W oxidation, fraction of non-tryptic termini, and fitted diagenetic index θ. JM-SP-0051 to JM-SP-0057 accessioned 2021–2023.MeasureN deamidationQ deamidationM oxidationW oxidationNon-tryptic terminiIndex θJM-SP-0001JM-SP-0001 × N deamidation: 0.910.91JM-SP-0001 × Q deamidation: 0.720.72JM-SP-0001 × M oxidation: 0.640.64JM-SP-0001 × W oxidation: 0.480.48JM-SP-0001 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.580.58JM-SP-0001 × Index θ: 0.810.81JM-SP-0011JM-SP-0011 × N deamidation: 0.890.89JM-SP-0011 × Q deamidation: 0.70.70JM-SP-0011 × M oxidation: 0.610.61JM-SP-0011 × W oxidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0011 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.570.57JM-SP-0011 × Index θ: 0.790.79JM-SP-0014JM-SP-0014 × N deamidation: 0.860.86JM-SP-0014 × Q deamidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0014 × M oxidation: 0.620.62JM-SP-0014 × W oxidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0014 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.550.55JM-SP-0014 × Index θ: 0.760.76JM-SP-0019JM-SP-0019 × N deamidation: 0.830.83JM-SP-0019 × Q deamidation: 0.630.63JM-SP-0019 × M oxidation: 0.590.59JM-SP-0019 × W oxidation: 0.410.41JM-SP-0019 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.520.52JM-SP-0019 × Index θ: 0.720.72JM-SP-0031JM-SP-0031 × N deamidation: 0.820.82JM-SP-0031 × Q deamidation: 0.590.59JM-SP-0031 × M oxidation: 0.570.57JM-SP-0031 × W oxidation: 0.390.39JM-SP-0031 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.490.49JM-SP-0031 × Index θ: 0.680.68JM-SP-0032JM-SP-0032 × N deamidation: 0.790.79JM-SP-0032 × Q deamidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0032 × M oxidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0032 × W oxidation: 0.370.37JM-SP-0032 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.470.47JM-SP-0032 × Index θ: 0.640.64JM-SP-0033JM-SP-0033 × N deamidation: 0.690.69JM-SP-0033 × Q deamidation: 0.410.41JM-SP-0033 × M oxidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0033 × W oxidation: 0.290.29JM-SP-0033 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.390.39JM-SP-0033 × Index θ: 0.510.51JM-SP-0034JM-SP-0034 × N deamidation: 0.710.71JM-SP-0034 × Q deamidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0034 × M oxidation: 0.490.49JM-SP-0034 × W oxidation: 0.310.31JM-SP-0034 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.410.41JM-SP-0034 × Index θ: 0.540.54JM-SP-0035JM-SP-0035 × N deamidation: 0.770.77JM-SP-0035 × Q deamidation: 0.520.52JM-SP-0035 × M oxidation: 0.530.53JM-SP-0035 × W oxidation: 0.360.36JM-SP-0035 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.460.46JM-SP-0035 × Index θ: 0.620.62JM-SP-0041JM-SP-0041 × N deamidation: 0.840.84JM-SP-0041 × Q deamidation: 0.620.62JM-SP-0041 × M oxidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0041 × W oxidation: 0.40.40JM-SP-0041 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.510.51JM-SP-0041 × Index θ: 0.70.70JM-SP-0042JM-SP-0042 × N deamidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0042 × Q deamidation: 0.380.38JM-SP-0042 × M oxidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0042 × W oxidation: 0.270.27JM-SP-0042 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.370.37JM-SP-0042 × Index θ: 0.480.48JM-SP-0043JM-SP-0043 × N deamidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0043 × Q deamidation: 0.290.29JM-SP-0043 × M oxidation: 0.710.71JM-SP-0043 × W oxidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0043 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.620.62JM-SP-0043 × Index θ: 0.550.55JM-SP-0044JM-SP-0044 × N deamidation: 0.610.61JM-SP-0044 × Q deamidation: 0.340.34JM-SP-0044 × M oxidation: 0.690.69JM-SP-0044 × W oxidation: 0.520.52JM-SP-0044 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.60.60JM-SP-0044 × Index θ: 0.570.57JM-SP-0045JM-SP-0045 × N deamidation: 0.720.72JM-SP-0045 × Q deamidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0045 × M oxidation: 0.480.48JM-SP-0045 × W oxidation: 0.320.32JM-SP-0045 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.420.42JM-SP-0045 × Index θ: 0.560.56JM-SP-0051JM-SP-0051 × N deamidation: 0.870.87JM-SP-0051 × Q deamidation: 0.670.67JM-SP-0051 × M oxidation: 0.60.60JM-SP-0051 × W oxidation: 0.430.43JM-SP-0051 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.540.54JM-SP-0051 × Index θ: 0.750.75JM-SP-0052JM-SP-0052 × N deamidation: 0.740.74JM-SP-0052 × Q deamidation: 0.470.47JM-SP-0052 × M oxidation: 0.510.51JM-SP-0052 × W oxidation: 0.330.33JM-SP-0052 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.440.44JM-SP-0052 × Index θ: 0.580.58JM-SP-0053JM-SP-0053 × N deamidation: 0.680.68JM-SP-0053 × Q deamidation: 0.40.40JM-SP-0053 × M oxidation: 0.450.45JM-SP-0053 × W oxidation: 0.280.28JM-SP-0053 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.380.38JM-SP-0053 × Index θ: 0.50.50JM-SP-0054JM-SP-0054 × N deamidation: 0.920.92JM-SP-0054 × Q deamidation: 0.760.76JM-SP-0054 × M oxidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0054 × W oxidation: 0.50.50JM-SP-0054 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.610.61JM-SP-0054 × Index θ: 0.840.84JM-SP-0055JM-SP-0055 × N deamidation: 0.730.73JM-SP-0055 × Q deamidation: 0.490.49JM-SP-0055 × M oxidation: 0.50.50JM-SP-0055 × W oxidation: 0.340.34JM-SP-0055 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.430.43JM-SP-0055 × Index θ: 0.590.59JM-SP-0056JM-SP-0056 × N deamidation: 0.810.81JM-SP-0056 × Q deamidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0056 × M oxidation: 0.560.56JM-SP-0056 × W oxidation: 0.380.38JM-SP-0056 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.480.48JM-SP-0056 × Index θ: 0.670.67JM-SP-0057JM-SP-0057 × N deamidation: 0.630.63JM-SP-0057 × Q deamidation: 0.360.36JM-SP-0057 × M oxidation: 0.670.67JM-SP-0057 × W oxidation: 0.510.51JM-SP-0057 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.590.59JM-SP-0057 × Index θ: 0.540.54Figure 1. Diagenetic profile by specimenFractional N and Q deamidation (at reference-conserved sites), M and W oxidation, fraction of non-tryptic termini, and fitted diagenetic index θ. JM-SP-0051 to JM-SP-0057 accessioned 2021–2023.MeasureN deamidationQ deamidationM oxidationW oxidationNon-tryptic terminiIndex θJM-SP-0001JM-SP-0001 × N deamidation: 0.910.91JM-SP-0001 × Q deamidation: 0.720.72JM-SP-0001 × M oxidation: 0.640.64JM-SP-0001 × W oxidation: 0.480.48JM-SP-0001 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.580.58JM-SP-0001 × Index θ: 0.810.81JM-SP-0011JM-SP-0011 × N deamidation: 0.890.89JM-SP-0011 × Q deamidation: 0.70.70JM-SP-0011 × M oxidation: 0.610.61JM-SP-0011 × W oxidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0011 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.570.57JM-SP-0011 × Index θ: 0.790.79JM-SP-0014JM-SP-0014 × N deamidation: 0.860.86JM-SP-0014 × Q deamidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0014 × M oxidation: 0.620.62JM-SP-0014 × W oxidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0014 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.550.55JM-SP-0014 × Index θ: 0.760.76JM-SP-0019JM-SP-0019 × N deamidation: 0.830.83JM-SP-0019 × Q deamidation: 0.630.63JM-SP-0019 × M oxidation: 0.590.59JM-SP-0019 × W oxidation: 0.410.41JM-SP-0019 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.520.52JM-SP-0019 × Index θ: 0.720.72JM-SP-0031JM-SP-0031 × N deamidation: 0.820.82JM-SP-0031 × Q deamidation: 0.590.59JM-SP-0031 × M oxidation: 0.570.57JM-SP-0031 × W oxidation: 0.390.39JM-SP-0031 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.490.49JM-SP-0031 × Index θ: 0.680.68JM-SP-0032JM-SP-0032 × N deamidation: 0.790.79JM-SP-0032 × Q deamidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0032 × M oxidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0032 × W oxidation: 0.370.37JM-SP-0032 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.470.47JM-SP-0032 × Index θ: 0.640.64JM-SP-0033JM-SP-0033 × N deamidation: 0.690.69JM-SP-0033 × Q deamidation: 0.410.41JM-SP-0033 × M oxidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0033 × W oxidation: 0.290.29JM-SP-0033 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.390.39JM-SP-0033 × Index θ: 0.510.51JM-SP-0034JM-SP-0034 × N deamidation: 0.710.71JM-SP-0034 × Q deamidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0034 × M oxidation: 0.490.49JM-SP-0034 × W oxidation: 0.310.31JM-SP-0034 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.410.41JM-SP-0034 × Index θ: 0.540.54JM-SP-0035JM-SP-0035 × N deamidation: 0.770.77JM-SP-0035 × Q deamidation: 0.520.52JM-SP-0035 × M oxidation: 0.530.53JM-SP-0035 × W oxidation: 0.360.36JM-SP-0035 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.460.46JM-SP-0035 × Index θ: 0.620.62JM-SP-0041JM-SP-0041 × N deamidation: 0.840.84JM-SP-0041 × Q deamidation: 0.620.62JM-SP-0041 × M oxidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0041 × W oxidation: 0.40.40JM-SP-0041 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.510.51JM-SP-0041 × Index θ: 0.70.70JM-SP-0042JM-SP-0042 × N deamidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0042 × Q deamidation: 0.380.38JM-SP-0042 × M oxidation: 0.440.44JM-SP-0042 × W oxidation: 0.270.27JM-SP-0042 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.370.37JM-SP-0042 × Index θ: 0.480.48JM-SP-0043JM-SP-0043 × N deamidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0043 × Q deamidation: 0.290.29JM-SP-0043 × M oxidation: 0.710.71JM-SP-0043 × W oxidation: 0.550.55JM-SP-0043 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.620.62JM-SP-0043 × Index θ: 0.550.55JM-SP-0044JM-SP-0044 × N deamidation: 0.610.61JM-SP-0044 × Q deamidation: 0.340.34JM-SP-0044 × M oxidation: 0.690.69JM-SP-0044 × W oxidation: 0.520.52JM-SP-0044 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.60.60JM-SP-0044 × Index θ: 0.570.57JM-SP-0045JM-SP-0045 × N deamidation: 0.720.72JM-SP-0045 × Q deamidation: 0.460.46JM-SP-0045 × M oxidation: 0.480.48JM-SP-0045 × W oxidation: 0.320.32JM-SP-0045 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.420.42JM-SP-0045 × Index θ: 0.560.56JM-SP-0051JM-SP-0051 × N deamidation: 0.870.87JM-SP-0051 × Q deamidation: 0.670.67JM-SP-0051 × M oxidation: 0.60.60JM-SP-0051 × W oxidation: 0.430.43JM-SP-0051 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.540.54JM-SP-0051 × Index θ: 0.750.75JM-SP-0052JM-SP-0052 × N deamidation: 0.740.74JM-SP-0052 × Q deamidation: 0.470.47JM-SP-0052 × M oxidation: 0.510.51JM-SP-0052 × W oxidation: 0.330.33JM-SP-0052 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.440.44JM-SP-0052 × Index θ: 0.580.58JM-SP-0053JM-SP-0053 × N deamidation: 0.680.68JM-SP-0053 × Q deamidation: 0.40.40JM-SP-0053 × M oxidation: 0.450.45JM-SP-0053 × W oxidation: 0.280.28JM-SP-0053 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.380.38JM-SP-0053 × Index θ: 0.50.50JM-SP-0054JM-SP-0054 × N deamidation: 0.920.92JM-SP-0054 × Q deamidation: 0.760.76JM-SP-0054 × M oxidation: 0.660.66JM-SP-0054 × W oxidation: 0.50.50JM-SP-0054 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.610.61JM-SP-0054 × Index θ: 0.840.84JM-SP-0055JM-SP-0055 × N deamidation: 0.730.73JM-SP-0055 × Q deamidation: 0.490.49JM-SP-0055 × M oxidation: 0.50.50JM-SP-0055 × W oxidation: 0.340.34JM-SP-0055 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.430.43JM-SP-0055 × Index θ: 0.590.59JM-SP-0056JM-SP-0056 × N deamidation: 0.810.81JM-SP-0056 × Q deamidation: 0.580.58JM-SP-0056 × M oxidation: 0.560.56JM-SP-0056 × W oxidation: 0.380.38JM-SP-0056 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.480.48JM-SP-0056 × Index θ: 0.670.67JM-SP-0057JM-SP-0057 × N deamidation: 0.630.63JM-SP-0057 × Q deamidation: 0.360.36JM-SP-0057 × M oxidation: 0.670.67JM-SP-0057 × W oxidation: 0.510.51JM-SP-0057 × Non-tryptic termini: 0.590.59JM-SP-0057 × Index θ: 0.540.54
Figure 1.Diagenetic profile by specimen. Fractional N and Q deamidation (at reference-conserved sites), M and W oxidation, fraction of non-tryptic termini, and fitted diagenetic index θ. JM-SP-0051 to JM-SP-0057 accessioned 2021–2023.Source: JM Shenzhen Research Center, diagenetic profiling run DG-2023-02.
Source data
SpecimenN deamidationQ deamidationM oxidationW oxidationNon-tryptic terminiIndex θ
JM-SP-00010.910.720.640.480.580.81
JM-SP-00110.890.70.610.460.570.79
JM-SP-00140.860.660.620.440.550.76
JM-SP-00190.830.630.590.410.520.72
JM-SP-00310.820.590.570.390.490.68
JM-SP-00320.790.550.550.370.470.64
JM-SP-00330.690.410.460.290.390.51
JM-SP-00340.710.440.490.310.410.54
JM-SP-00350.770.520.530.360.460.62
JM-SP-00410.840.620.580.40.510.7
JM-SP-00420.660.380.440.270.370.48
JM-SP-00430.580.290.710.550.620.55
JM-SP-00440.610.340.690.520.60.57
JM-SP-00450.720.460.480.320.420.56
JM-SP-00510.870.670.60.430.540.75
JM-SP-00520.740.470.510.330.440.58
JM-SP-00530.680.40.450.280.380.5
JM-SP-00540.920.760.660.50.610.84
JM-SP-00550.730.490.50.340.430.59
JM-SP-00560.810.580.560.380.480.67
JM-SP-00570.630.360.670.510.590.54

Figure 2. Q deamidation versus Asx racemizationFractional Q deamidation at reference-conserved sites against Asx D/L in the acid-insoluble fraction, for the 14 specimens with chiral amino acid data. Linear fit: slope 0.98, R² = 0.95. JM-SP-0001 was not subsampled.Fractional Q deamidation0.000.200.400.600.801.000.10.20.30.40.50.60.7Asx D/LSpecimens linear fit: y = 0.981x + 0.0817, R² = 0.95JM-SP-0043 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.21 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.29JM-SP-0043JM-SP-0042 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.26 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.38JM-SP-0057 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.33 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.36JM-SP-0057JM-SP-0033 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.29 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.41JM-SP-0053 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.35 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.40JM-SP-0052 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.41 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.47JM-SP-0034 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.38 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.44JM-SP-0055 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.44 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.49JM-SP-0035 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.47 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.52JM-SP-0032 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.49 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.55JM-SP-0032JM-SP-0041 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.55 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.62JM-SP-0041JM-SP-0019 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.52 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.63JM-SP-0014 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.58 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.66JM-SP-0011 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.61 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.70JM-SP-0011Figure 2. Q deamidation versus Asx racemizationFractional Q deamidation at reference-conserved sites against Asx D/L in the acid-insoluble fraction, for the 14 specimens with chiral amino acid data. Linear fit: slope 0.98, R² = 0.95. JM-SP-0001 was not subsampled.Fractional Q deamidation0.000.200.400.600.801.000.10.20.30.40.50.60.7Asx D/LSpecimens linear fit: y = 0.981x + 0.0817, R² = 0.95JM-SP-0043 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.21 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.29JM-SP-0043JM-SP-0042 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.26 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.38JM-SP-0057 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.33 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.36JM-SP-0033 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.29 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.41JM-SP-0053 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.35 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.40JM-SP-0052 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.41 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.47JM-SP-0034 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.38 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.44JM-SP-0055 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.44 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.49JM-SP-0035 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.47 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.52JM-SP-0032 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.49 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.55JM-SP-0032JM-SP-0041 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.55 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.62JM-SP-0019 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.52 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.63JM-SP-0014 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.58 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.66JM-SP-0011 Specimens Asx D/L: 0.61 Fractional Q deamidation: 0.70
Figure 2.Q deamidation versus Asx racemization. Fractional Q deamidation at reference-conserved sites against Asx D/L in the acid-insoluble fraction, for the 14 specimens with chiral amino acid data. Linear fit: slope 0.98, R² = 0.95. JM-SP-0001 was not subsampled.Source: JM Shenzhen Research Center, chiral amino acid analysis series AA-2022/2023.
Source data
LabelAsx D/LFractional Q deamidation
JM-SP-00430.210.29
JM-SP-00420.260.38
JM-SP-00570.330.36
JM-SP-00330.290.41
JM-SP-00530.350.4
JM-SP-00520.410.47
JM-SP-00340.380.44
JM-SP-00550.440.49
JM-SP-00350.470.52
JM-SP-00320.490.55
JM-SP-00410.550.62
JM-SP-00190.520.63
JM-SP-00140.580.66
JM-SP-00110.610.7

The diagenetic model's treatment of each modification class, and the number of residue calls affected in v2.8, is summarised in Table 2.

Table 2. Diagenetic modification classes and their treatment in v2.8 scoring.
Class Residues Observable by LC-MS/MS Treatment in v2.8 Residue calls affected
Deamidation N→D, Q→E Partly (mass shift +0.984 Da; indistinguishable from D/E when complete) Off-diagonal terms in D(θ); conserved-site prior 1,104 reclassified from substitution
Oxidation M, W, H Yes (mass shifts) Reduced confidence weight; identity unchanged 2,471 down-weighted
Backbone cleavage Any; elevated at Asp–Xaa and Asn Indirectly (non-tryptic termini) Terminal residues down-weighted; length term 3,918 termini down-weighted
Racemization Asx principally No (requires chiral analysis) Enters via θ and retention-time tolerance Not applicable per residue

4.3 Effect on placement

Under v2.3 scoring, placement confidence declined steeply with the number of deamidated residues in a fragment (Fig. 3). Under v2.8 scoring, the decline is largely removed. The effect is concentrated in the 486 fragments with two or more deamidated residues, which are also those with the strongest evidence of age.

Figure 3. Placement confidence by deamidation load, v2.3 and v2.8 scoringMedian posterior placement probability for v2.8 library fragments grouped by number of deamidated residues (annotated or inferred). Band: interquartile range under v2.8 scoring. Fragments per group: 1,212; 538; 274; 121; 56; 35.Posterior placement probability0.000.200.400.600.801.0001234≥5Deamidated residues per fragmentv2.3 scoringv2.8 scoringDeamidated residues per fragment: 0 v2.3 scoring: 0.70 v2.8 scoring: 0.72 (0.55–0.85)Deamidated residues per fragment: 1 v2.3 scoring: 0.66 v2.8 scoring: 0.71 (0.54–0.84)Deamidated residues per fragment: 2 v2.3 scoring: 0.58 v2.8 scoring: 0.69 (0.51–0.83)Deamidated residues per fragment: 3 v2.3 scoring: 0.49 v2.8 scoring: 0.66 (0.47–0.81)Deamidated residues per fragment: 4 v2.3 scoring: 0.41 v2.8 scoring: 0.62 (0.41–0.79)Deamidated residues per fragment: ≥5 v2.3 scoring: 0.33 v2.8 scoring: 0.57 (0.34–0.77)Figure 3. Placement confidence by deamidation load, v2.3 and v2.8 scoringMedian posterior placement probability for v2.8 library fragments grouped by number of deamidated residues (annotated or inferred). Band: interquartile range under v2.8 scoring. Fragments per group: 1,212; 538; 274; 121; 56; 35.Posterior placement probability0.000.200.400.600.801.0001234≥5Deamidated residues per fragmentDeamidated residues per fragment: 0 v2.3 scoring: 0.70 v2.8 scoring: 0.72 (0.55–0.85)Deamidated residues per fragment: 1 v2.3 scoring: 0.66 v2.8 scoring: 0.71 (0.54–0.84)Deamidated residues per fragment: 2 v2.3 scoring: 0.58 v2.8 scoring: 0.69 (0.51–0.83)Deamidated residues per fragment: 3 v2.3 scoring: 0.49 v2.8 scoring: 0.66 (0.47–0.81)Deamidated residues per fragment: 4 v2.3 scoring: 0.41 v2.8 scoring: 0.62 (0.41–0.79)Deamidated residues per fragment: ≥5 v2.3 scoring: 0.33 v2.8 scoring: 0.57 (0.34–0.77)
Figure 3.Placement confidence by deamidation load, v2.3 and v2.8 scoring. Median posterior placement probability for v2.8 library fragments grouped by number of deamidated residues (annotated or inferred). Band: interquartile range under v2.8 scoring. Fragments per group: 1,212; 538; 274; 121; 56; 35.Source: JM Shenzhen Research Center, build manifest v2.8.
Source data
Deamidated residues per fragmentv2.3 scoringv2.8 scoringv2.8 scoring interval
00.70.720.55–0.85
10.660.710.54–0.84
20.580.690.51–0.83
30.490.660.47–0.81
40.410.620.41–0.79
≥50.330.570.34–0.77

Per-fragment posterior increased for 1,561 fragments and decreased for 675 (30.2%) (Fig. 4). Decreases are concentrated in fragments whose placement had depended on a D or E residue at a reference-conserved N or Q site, that is, on a residue the model now attributes to deamidation rather than to inheritance.

Figure 4. Change in per-fragment placement posterior, v2.8 minus v2.3 scoringAll 2,236 v2.8 fragments, scored under both models on the 57-taxon reference set with all overrides applied. 675 fragments (30.2%) show a decrease.Fragments02004006008001,000−0.30−0.20−0.10−0.050.000.050.100.200.300.40−0.3–−0.2: 21−0.2–−0.1: 88−0.1–−0.05: 164−0.05–0: 4020–0.05: 9170.05–0.1: 3410.1–0.2: 2120.2–0.3: 710.3–0.4: 20Change in posterior placement probabilityFigure 4. Change in per-fragment placement posterior, v2.8 minus v2.3 scoringAll 2,236 v2.8 fragments, scored under both models on the 57-taxon reference set with all overrides applied. 675 fragments (30.2%) show a decrease.Fragments02004006008001,000−0.20.00.20.4−0.3–−0.2: 21−0.2–−0.1: 88−0.1–−0.05: 164−0.05–0: 4020–0.05: 9170.05–0.1: 3410.1–0.2: 2120.2–0.3: 710.3–0.4: 20Change in posterior placement probability
Figure 4.Change in per-fragment placement posterior, v2.8 minus v2.3 scoring. All 2,236 v2.8 fragments, scored under both models on the 57-taxon reference set with all overrides applied. 675 fragments (30.2%) show a decrease.Source: JM Shenzhen Research Center, build manifest v2.8.
Source data
Change in posterior placement probabilityFragments
−0.3–−0.221
−0.2–−0.188
−0.1–−0.05164
−0.05–0402
0–0.05917
0.05–0.1341
0.1–0.2212
0.2–0.371
0.3–0.420

The ablation in Table 3 separates the contributions of the reference-set expansion, the diagenetic model and the override flags to the headline median. The reported figure for v2.8 (0.71) is computed with all active overrides applied, consistent with every previous release. Re-scored under the v2.8 model, the v2.3 entry set has a median of 0.68 (run A′); the v2.3 figure as released (0.66) is not restated.

Table 3. Ablation of median placement posterior (theropod-assigned fragments).
Run Library Reference taxa Scoring Overrides applied Median posterior
A v2.3 41 v2.3 All 0.66
A′ v2.3 41 v2.8 All 0.68
B v2.8 57 v2.3 All 0.68
C v2.8 57 v2.8 All 0.71 (reported)
D v2.8 57 v2.8 Only those ≤24 months old 0.69
E v2.8 57 v2.8 None 0.67
F v2.8 57 v2.3 None 0.64

The consensus placement under v2.8 scoring remains on the avian stem (Fig. 5).

Figure 5. Consensus placement of theropod-assigned fragments, Library v2.8Simplified reference topology (14 of 57 extant reference taxa shown). p is the median posterior on the avian stem with all overrides applied (run C, Table 3). With overrides disabled (run E), p = 0.67.JM theropodp = 0.71JM theropod — placement posterior 0.71StruthioStruthioRheaRheaDromaiusDromaiusTinamusTinamusGallusGallusMeleagrisMeleagrisAnasAnasColumbaColumbaFalcoFalcoTaeniopygiaTaeniopygiaAlligatorAlligatorCaimanCaimanCrocodylusCrocodylusGavialisGavialisChrysemysChrysemysFigure 5. Consensus placement of theropod-assigned fragments, Library v2.8Simplified reference topology (14 of 57 extant reference taxa shown). p is the median posterior on the avian stem with all overrides applied (run C, Table 3). With overrides disabled (run E), p = 0.67.JM theropodp = 0.71JM theropod — placement posterior 0.71StruthioStruthioRheaRheaDromaiusDromaiusTinamusTinamusGallusGallusMeleagrisMeleagrisAnasAnasColumbaColumbaFalcoFalcoTaeniopygiaTaeniopygiaAlligatorAlligatorCaimanCaimanCrocodylusCrocodylusGavialisGavialisChrysemysChrysemys
Figure 5.Consensus placement of theropod-assigned fragments, Library v2.8. Simplified reference topology (14 of 57 extant reference taxa shown). p is the median posterior on the avian stem with all overrides applied (run C, Table 3). With overrides disabled (run E), p = 0.67.Source: JM Shenzhen Research Center, build manifest v2.8.
Source data
TaxonHighlightedPlacement posterior
JM theropodyes0.71
Struthio
Rhea
Dromaius
Tinamus
Gallus
Meleagris
Anas
Columba
Falco
Taeniopygia
Alligator
Caiman
Crocodylus
Gavialis
Chrysemys

(((JM_theropod,((Struthio,(Rhea,(Dromaius,Tinamus))),(((Gallus,Meleagris),Anas),(Columba,(Falco,Taeniopygia))))),((Alligator,Caiman),(Crocodylus,Gavialis))),Chrysemys);

4.4 Theropod-diagnostic columns

Library v2.0 defined 31 alignment columns at which theropod-assigned fragments carry a residue absent from all extant reference taxa (JM-TR-2019-004, Table 1). These columns have been cited internally as the most direct sequence-level evidence of a non-avian theropod source. Under v2.8 scoring, nine of the 31 are reclassified as probable deamidation products: in each, the theropod residue is D or E and every one of the 57 reference taxa carries N or Q (Table 4). The remaining 22 columns are retained as diagnostic. Seven of the nine reclassified columns carry PIN_RESIDUE overrides, created between 2019 and 2021, which fix the theropod residue as D or E. Overrides take precedence over the model (Section 3.6), and in default builds these seven columns therefore continue to be scored as diagnostic.

Table 4. Theropod-diagnostic columns reclassified as probable deamidation.
Column Locus Reference residue (57/57 taxa) Theropod residue Fragments Deamidation posterior PIN_RESIDUE override
C1A1-0412 COL1A1 N D 38 0.97 Yes (2019)
C1A1-0587 COL1A1 Q E 22 0.91 Yes (2019)
C1A1-0903 COL1A1 N D 41 0.98 Yes (2019)
C1A2-0219 COL1A2 N D 17 0.94 Yes (2020)
C1A2-0656 COL1A2 Q E 13 0.86 No
C1A2-0871 COL1A2 N D 29 0.96 Yes (2020)
AMLX-0044 AMELX Q E 11 0.88 Yes (2021)
ENAM-0130 ENAM N D 6 0.83 No
C1A1-1024 COL1A1 N D 19 0.95 Yes (2021)

4.5 Effect on reconstruction targets

Re-inference of all 19 current reconstruction targets under v2.8 scoring changed inferred residues at 12 positions in five targets. Three changes fall in targets incorporated in the production cell line DN-2019-04 (JM-TR-2019-004); all three are at sites with posterior below 0.6 under both scorings and lie outside the regions characterised for that line in 2021. Impact assessment IA-2023-03 concluded that there was no impact on released material. The assessment was reviewed by the Ethics & Bioresponsibility Council on 22 August 2023: reviewed; no concerns raised.

4.6 Override inventory

At the v2.7 freeze there were 4,118 active override flags in a library of 2,236 fragments (Table 5). Overrides are not evenly distributed: 61% apply to 14% of fragments, principally those from JM-SP-0001 and the ungual specimens. Of the 4,118, 3,342 (81.2%) were older than 24 months, 1,906 (46.3%) had no recorded rationale, and 1,207 (29.3%) were legacy records converted at the v2.0 migration: the 41 flags carried from v1.x and 1,166 records inferred from unflagged manual edits in the legacy files, all attributed to the migration service account jm-curate because individual attribution was not recorded at the time (JM-TR-2019-004, Section 6).

Table 5. Active override flags at the v2.7 freeze (2023-08-31), by type.
Type Effect Active Older than 24 months No recorded rationale
FORCE_INCLUDE Entry included regardless of filters and exclusion rules 1,184 961 502
FORCE_EXCLUDE Entry excluded regardless of scoring 391 318 140
PIN_PLACEMENT Placement fixed to a specified branch 742 655 377
PIN_RESIDUE Residue at a column fixed to a specified value 1,513 1,214 742
SUPPRESS_CONTAM Contamination-database match disregarded 288 194 145
Total 4,118 3,342 1,906

Further findings from the inventory:

  • 388 PIN_RESIDUE overrides fix a D or E at a position the v2.8 model classifies as probable deamidation (posterior > 0.8). Seven of these are the diagnostic columns in Table 4.
  • 41 SUPPRESS_CONTAM overrides apply to keratin-associated fragments, including the four described in JM-TR-2021-005, Section 4.2.
  • 63 fragments carry both a FORCE_INCLUDE and a FORCE_EXCLUDE override. These are resolved by the build system's precedence rule, under which the more recent override applies. This rule is documented here for the first time.
  • 17 overrides reference fragment identifiers that do not exist in the library, as a result of the renumbering at the v2.0 migration. They have no effect and have been retained for audit.
  • In v1.x, fragments with placement overrides were excluded from per-fragment placement statistics (JM-TR-2014-002). Since v2.0 they have been included at their pinned placement. This change was made at migration to preserve build equivalence and was not separately documented.
  • PIN_PLACEMENT overrides contribute 0.02 of the headline median posterior (Table 3, runs C and D) and all override types together contribute 0.04 (runs C and E).

The age profile of overrides is shown in Fig. 6. The largest single year of creation is 2021, which coincides with the curation of the keratin-associated peptides for v2.3.

Figure 6. Active override flags by year of creationOverrides active at the v2.7 freeze (n = 4,118), stacked by age relative to the 24-month deprecation threshold (created before 2021-08-31). Legacy: v1.x override flags and unflagged manual edits converted at v2.0, attributed to the service account jm-curate.Active overrides02004006008001,0001,2001,400Legacy (converted2019)Legacy (converted 2019) Older than 24 months (deprecated): 1,207 Total: 1,2071,20720192019 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 498 Total: 49849820202020 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 731 Total: 73173120212021 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 906 Total: 1,1472021 24 months or newer: 241 Total: 1,1471,14720222022 24 months or newer: 402 Total: 40240220232023 24 months or newer: 133 Total: 133133Year of creationFigure 6. Active override flags by year of creationOverrides active at the v2.7 freeze (n = 4,118), stacked by age relative to the 24-month deprecation threshold (created before 2021-08-31). Legacy: v1.x override flags and unflagged manual edits converted at v2.0, attributed to the service account jm-curate.04008001,200Legacy (converted2019)Legacy (converted 2019) Older than 24 months (deprecated): 1,207 Total: 1,2071,20720192019 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 498 Total: 49849820202020 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 731 Total: 73173120212021 Older than 24 months (deprecated): 906 Total: 1,1472021 24 months or newer: 241 Total: 1,1471,14720222022 24 months or newer: 402 Total: 40240220232023 24 months or newer: 133 Total: 133133Active overrides
Figure 6.Active override flags by year of creation. Overrides active at the v2.7 freeze (n = 4,118), stacked by age relative to the 24-month deprecation threshold (created before 2021-08-31). Legacy: v1.x override flags and unflagged manual edits converted at v2.0, attributed to the service account jm-curate.Source: Override register, snapshot at v2.7 freeze.
Source data
Year of creationOlder than 24 months (deprecated)24 months or newer
Legacy (converted 2019)1,2070
20194980
20207310
2021906241
20220402
20230133

4.7 Deprecation and review

Overrides older than 24 months are deprecated in v2.8. A deprecated override emits warning W-OVR-24M at build time and continues to apply. It is removed only when reviewed and retired; it ceases to be deprecated when reviewed and renewed with a recorded rationale, which is now mandatory for renewal. Review began on 3 July 2023. Its status at release is shown in Table 6.

Table 6. Review status of overrides older than 24 months, at release.
Status Overrides
Older than 24 months at v2.7 freeze 3,342
Reviewed and renewed (rationale recorded) 318
Reviewed and retired 94
Not yet reviewed (deprecated; in effect) 2,930
Active overrides at v2.8 release 4,024
W-OVR-24M warnings emitted by a default v2.8 build 2,930

At the current review rate, which is limited by the need to re-examine raw spectra for many PIN_RESIDUE and SUPPRESS_CONTAM overrides, review of the remaining deprecated overrides is expected to take approximately 30 months. All build warnings are written to the build log, which is retained with each release (JM-TR-2019-004, CA-4).

5. Discussion

The diagenesis-aware model does what it was designed to do. Placement confidence is no longer penalised for the modification that most strongly indicates age, and the headline median rises from 0.68 to 0.71 on the same library and reference set. The direction of this result is reassuring: the most heavily modified fragments, those least likely to be modern contaminants, were the ones the previous scoring placed least well, and are now placed comparably to unmodified fragments.

The reclassification of nine diagnostic columns requires a more careful statement. Each of those columns shows a D or E in the fossil where all 57 living relatives carry N or Q. That is the pattern expected from a genuine substitution on the theropod lineage, and it is also exactly the pattern expected from deamidation. The previous scoring could not distinguish the two and did not try. The v2.8 model assigns each a deamidation posterior between 0.83 and 0.98. Placement on the avian stem is the expectation under the extant phylogenetic bracket (Witmer 1995). We do not regard this as evidence against a theropod source, which rests on the 22 remaining columns and on the joint placement of 2,236 fragments, but these nine columns should no longer be cited as diagnostic. That seven of them continue to be scored as diagnostic in default builds, through PIN_RESIDUE overrides created before the diagenetic model existed, illustrates the governance problem addressed in the second half of this release.

Overrides were introduced to make manual decisions visible and attributable. The inventory shows that they are visible. It also shows that they accumulate: the library now carries more overrides than fragments, almost half without a rationale, and the oldest and most numerous were inherited from a period in which curation decisions were not attributed to individuals. Overrides are not in themselves errors. Many of those reviewed so far were renewed, and a curation decision taken with the spectrum in front of the curator may be better than any automated rule. However, an override has no expiry, takes precedence over every subsequent improvement to the scoring, and, as runs C to E in Table 3 show, contributes measurably to the confidence figure we report. A 24-month deprecation threshold is a first step. We chose deprecation with warnings rather than automatic expiry because automatic expiry would change 3,342 entries at once, and the v2.0 post-mortem gave us a durable aversion to large unexamined changes in build behaviour.

6. Limitations and known issues

  • Overrides take precedence over the diagenetic model. 388 PIN_RESIDUE overrides fix a residue the model attributes to deamidation, including seven of nine reclassified diagnostic columns.
  • 2,930 deprecated overrides remain in effect pending review. A default build emits 2,930 warnings.
  • The reported median posterior (0.71) includes the effect of overrides. Without overrides it is 0.67.
  • 63 fragments carry contradictory include/exclude overrides, resolved by recency.
  • 17 overrides reference fragments that do not exist.
  • Racemization data are available for 14 of 21 specimens; θ is imputed for the remainder. JM-SP-0001 was not subsampled for chiral analysis: its remaining crown material is reserved under the foundational-specimen provision (JM-TR-2016-003).
  • The model assumes all modification is post-mortem. Deamidation accumulating in long-lived proteins during the life of the animal is not distinguished.
  • Deamidation rates are context-dependent at a finer scale than the model's context multipliers capture, including dependence on local structure that is not available for fossil material.
  • Keratin-associated fragments (121) remain flagged and included at full weight.
  • Fragments shorter than eight residues remain poorly placed under both scorings.
  • Clade-targeted build filters remain user-specified and are not validated against the target clade. A mis-set filter is not detected at build time.

7. Changes in Library v2.8

  • Improved handling of diagenetically altered residues.
  • Deprecated manual override flags older than 24 months.

Also listed in the release notes for v2.8:

  • 626 theropod-assigned fossil-derived entries added (1,610 → 2,236); sixteen extant reference taxa added (41 → 57).
  • Unaligned legacy peptide files (deprecated in v2.0) removed. All legacy content had been converted.
  • Fixed: the contamination exclusion list was not applied to identifications supported by de novo sequencing alone. Affected entries were re-screened; the reclassified entries are listed in the v2.8 validation report. No affected entry contributed to a production target sequence.
  • Fixed: the build manifest reported reference taxa counts that included two duplicate species entered under a former and a current scientific name. Corrected before release; the released count (57) excludes the duplicates.
  • Known issue: racemization estimates are unavailable for seven of 21 specimens, including JM-SP-0001 (KI-0519; Section 6).

The diagenetic model is described in Sections 3.2–3.4 and 4.2–4.5; override deprecation in Sections 3.6 and 4.6–4.7.

8. Data availability

Library contents are confidential. Library access is restricted to authorized research staff and is not available to third parties. The override register and build logs are available to auditors and regulators on request under confidentiality. Aggregate statistics are derived from build manifest v2.8, diagenetic profiling run DG-2023-02 and the override register snapshot of 31 August 2023. Questions about this report may be directed to regulatory@jurassicmeat.com.

9. Acknowledgements

We thank the mass spectrometry suite staff for the re-examination of archived spectra during override review, Marcus Oyelaran for coordinating subsampling for chiral analysis under the custody procedure, and Dr. Rahul Venkataraman for re-inference of reconstruction targets. We thank the curators, past and present, whose decisions are inventoried in Section 4.6. The override review and IA-2023-03 were reviewed by the Ethics & Bioresponsibility Council: reviewed; no concerns raised. This work was funded internally. All authors are employees of Jurassic Meat and may hold equity.

10. References

  1. Asara JM, et al. (2007). Protein sequences from mastodon and Tyrannosaurus rex revealed by mass spectrometry. Science 316:280–285.
  2. Buckley M, et al. (2008). Comment on "Protein sequences from mastodon and Tyrannosaurus rex revealed by mass spectrometry." Science 319:33.
  3. Cappellini E, et al. (2019). Early Pleistocene enamel proteome from Dmanisi resolves Stephanorhinus phylogeny. Nature 574:103–107.
  4. Cox J, Mann M (2008). MaxQuant enables high peptide identification rates, individualized p.p.b.-range mass accuracies and proteome-wide protein quantification. Nature Biotechnology 26:1367–1372.
  5. Demarchi B, et al. (2016). Protein sequences bound to mineral surfaces persist into deep time. eLife 5:e17092.
  6. Saitta ET, et al. (2019). Cretaceous dinosaur bone contains recent organic material and provides an environment conducive to microbial communities. eLife 8:e46205.
  7. Schweitzer MH, et al. (2009). Biomolecular characterization and protein sequences of the Campanian hadrosaur B. canadensis. Science 324:626–631.
  8. Welker F, et al. (2019). Enamel proteome shows that Gigantopithecus was an early diverging pongine. Nature 576:262–265.
  9. Witmer LM (1995). The extant phylogenetic bracket and the importance of reconstructing soft tissues in fossils. In: Thomason JJ (ed.), Functional Morphology in Vertebrate Paleontology. Cambridge University Press, 19–33.
  10. JM-TR-2013-001. Endogenous peptide fragments recovered from a Kem Kem Group theropod tooth. Jurassic Meat internal technical report.
  11. JM-TR-2019-004. Library v2.0: a versioned multiple-sequence-alignment architecture for fragmentary ancient peptides. Jurassic Meat internal technical report.
  12. JM-TR-2021-005. Library v2.3: keratin-associated peptides and a chain-of-custody metadata schema. Jurassic Meat internal technical report.